The Best Dog Calming Collars (2021 Reviews)

Skylar Dial
Written by
Last update:

Dog calming collars can help you transform your dog into a much calmer, happier, and more obedient companion, and in this guide, we will show you which ones are the best dog calming collars to give you real results.

This way, you don’t have to suffer through a barky or destructive dog and your dog can have a much more peaceful and pleasant life.

I have personally used calming collars such as citronella, static, and ultrasonic on my own dog like you can see in the image on this page, and I can say with certainty that they do work.

It is important to note that these products are not intended to be a cure-all for your dog’s behavior problems, but they can certainly help you manage things a lot better than they would without them.

NameCategoryProduct
Calm Me DownBest OverallCalm Me Down
NurtureCALM 24/7 Pheromone CollarBudget PickNurtureCALM 24/7 Pheromone Collar
Calm Me DownUpgrade PickCalm Me Down

1. Calm Me Down

Our rating: 9 / 10

Calm Me Down

Check Price on Amazon

Shock Collars and Bark Control Collars.

According to reviews, the PetSafe bark collar is one of the best bark collars on the market. This collar uses a citronella spray to keep your dog quiet. The citronella spray is released when your dog barks, startling them into thinking someone is out to get them.

Post-sales service is exceptional. Along with the collar, you’ll get a manual, a CD, and a few AA batteries.

2. NurtureCALM 24/7 Pheromone Collar

Our rating: 7 / 10

NurtureCALM 24/7 Pheromone Collar

Check Price on Amazon

We love that this natural necklace features a calming pheromone formula from the mother of all pheromone canine calming collars — the mother dog.

Mother dogs are great at comforting their pups and now you can try the same pheromone as your dog to keep them calm and relax. The relief pheromones refill comes with a money back guarantee so you can access the ingredients used in this formula.

This is a very good choice for our pick for the best dog calming collar. The Pheromone is the scent released by the mother dog, which is used to comfort the puppies. This can help calm a dog down. We find it a great way to calm a dog down when they have anxiety attacks, or are over excited.

3. Calm Me Down

Our rating: 7 / 10

Calm Me Down

Check Price on Amazon

Shock Collars and Bark Control Collars.

According to reviews, the PetSafe bark collar is one of the best bark collars on the market. This collar uses a citronella spray to keep your dog quiet. The citronella spray is released when your dog barks, startling them into thinking someone is out to get them.

Post-sales service is exceptional. Along with the collar, you’ll get a manual, a CD, and a few AA batteries.

4. Calm Paws Dog Caring Collar

Our rating: 7 / 10

Calm Paws Dog Caring Collar

Check Price on Amazon

The Calm Paws dog collar works by giving out a gentle pulse at the moment your dog begins to bark. The collar then repeats the action until your dog lays back down. This process helps to relax your dog so that it can better associate the collar’s vibrations to the process of smoking.

The gentle pulses from the collar cannot be felt by humans or encouraged pets. The device is suitable for all breeds of dogs – weighing between 2 and 2.5 lbs. According to the devices’ manufacturer, the collar is suitable for a variety of dog-related challenges including separation anxiety, sleeping disorders, fear, etc.

However, it has only been tested on a limited number of dogs and its performance on a wide variety of dogs has not been established.

5. Sentry Calming Collar

Our rating: 7 / 10

Sentry Calming Collar

Check Price on Amazon

The Sentry Calming Collar for Dogs is an anti-bark collar that is designed to reduce excessive barking. It has a patented system of pulsing or beeping that you can control with a remote.

This anti-barking collar is an electronic device that is placed around a dog’s neck. It has a sensor that detects vibrations from a dog’s throat when it’s barking. The vibration triggers a beeping or a vibration sensation through a built-in vibration mechanism.

This collar is typically used by owners who are having trouble managing their dogs’ abnormal barking. The vibration or beeping only comes for a minute or so, after which the collar begins a period of what’s called “time out” and stops vibrating or beeping.

6. Adaptil Calm On-The-Go-Collar

Our rating: 6 / 10

Adaptil Calm On-The-Go-Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Helps protect your pet from excessive stress that may cause health problems
  • Keeps your pet calm and comfortable even when it’s left alone in a strange place
  • An odorless spray that is applied to furniture, clothing, and bedding to calm and comfort your pet (so be careful of the spray, it can stain)
  • A non-invasive spray that is quickly absorbed
  • The spray mimics the pheromone released by a mother during birth
  • The spray treats pets that are afraid of storms, fireworks, travel, grooming, strangers, and tense situations,
  • Most pets respond within 1-3 days, max in a week
  • Dogs and cats of good health and temperament, 10 weeks and up, with a maximum weight of 143lbs
  • Control capsules can help your dog or cat balance stress with routine and help him remain calm while getting used to new homes, environments, socialization, grooming, it reduces stress created by pups that are hungry, or sick
  • Fast-acting capsule with delayed release

7. Adaptil Calm On-The-Go-Collar

Our rating: 6 / 10

Adaptil Calm On-The-Go-Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Helps protect your pet from excessive stress that may cause health problems
  • Keeps your pet calm and comfortable even when it’s left alone in a strange place
  • An odorless spray that is applied to furniture, clothing, and bedding to calm and comfort your pet (so be careful of the spray, it can stain)
  • A non-invasive spray that is quickly absorbed
  • The spray mimics the pheromone released by a mother during birth
  • The spray treats pets that are afraid of storms, fireworks, travel, grooming, strangers, and tense situations,
  • Most pets respond within 1-3 days, max in a week
  • Dogs and cats of good health and temperament, 10 weeks and up, with a maximum weight of 143lbs
  • Control capsules can help your dog or cat balance stress with routine and help him remain calm while getting used to new homes, environments, socialization, grooming, it reduces stress created by pups that are hungry, or sick
  • Fast-acting capsule with delayed release

8. Sentry Calming Collar

Our rating: 6 / 10

Sentry Calming Collar

Check Price on Amazon

The Sentry Calming Collar for Dogs is an anti-bark collar that is designed to reduce excessive barking. It has a patented system of pulsing or beeping that you can control with a remote.

This anti-barking collar is an electronic device that is placed around a dog’s neck. It has a sensor that detects vibrations from a dog’s throat when it’s barking. The vibration triggers a beeping or a vibration sensation through a built-in vibration mechanism.

This collar is typically used by owners who are having trouble managing their dogs’ abnormal barking. The vibration or beeping only comes for a minute or so, after which the collar begins a period of what’s called “time out” and stops vibrating or beeping.

9. Adaptil Adjustable Calming Dog Collar

Our rating: 5 / 10

Adaptil Adjustable Calming Dog Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Adjustable collar fits a variety of breeds
  • Two levels of static stimulation
  • Constant pheromone release
  • Reduces or stops distress barking
  • Quality construction; lasts for years

Don’t let the name fool you, this collar is safe for cats too! The Adaptil Dog Calming Collar is perfect for dogs that are easily frightened by thunderstorms, fireworks, or gunshots.

Adapting to dog anxiety requires an appropriate response when your pet is feeling stressed.

Adaptil Calming Dog Collar is safe for all breeds, and helps your dog to deal with fears, stress, noise phobias, car rides, and new people/dogs.

10. Adaptil 3 Pack OnTheGo Collar

Our rating: 5 / 10

Adaptil 3 Pack OnTheGo Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • It’s odorless and non-greasy
  • It’s easy to use
  • Contains natural active ingredients
  • Available in a 3-pack
  • The individual collars are not too bulky
  • Provides a calm and relaxed feeling for your dog
  • You can adjust the intensity of the smell
  • Recommended by vets
  • Provides a soothing smell that’s safe for your dog’s health

Cons:

  • It’s not as effective on dogs that tend to spray and drool
  • It doesn’t work immediately
  • Not a long-term solution
  • You might have to reapply it for best results

If there’s one thing Bichon owners talk about, it’s probably the odor that their dogs’ hair gives off. Fortunately, Adaptil can help you manage that particular issue. With the 3-pack of odor control collars, you’ll be able to give your Bichon a pleasant smell.

The Adaptil collar works by gently releasing a chemical component that prevents your dog’s skin from producing a protein that causes the bad odor.

11. Adaptil Large Dog Collar

Our rating: 5 / 10

Adaptil Large Dog Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy-to-use, easy-to-carry
  • Gentle and effective
  • Useful for separation anxiety and noise anxiety
  • Great value

Cons:

  • Some people report not seeing any difference in their dog
  • Some people report that the spray is disruptive

The Adaptil Collar for dogs is an easy-to-use, easy-to-carry and affordable spray that is designed to curb your dog’s anxiety. It comes in two sizes – small and large, and can be used in conjunction with tablets or patches to help calm your dog down.

The Adaptil PetCalm collar releases a synthetic pheromone called DAP. The pheromone contains two types of hormones – the “comforting” hormone, and the “alerting” hormone.

Both these hormones help to make your dog relax and feel comfortable and settled. The DAP also has a calming effect. The Adaptil PetCalm collar also comes with a spray that is applied to your dog’s bed, which will also help it feel comfortable and calm.

12. PetGuard Herbal Dog Collar

Our rating: 5 / 10

PetGuard Herbal Dog Collar

Check Price on Amazon

The PetGuard dog collar is specially formulated to soothe and comfort anxiety and nervous dogs.

With this product, you no longer have to resort to traditional anti-anxiety meds, or even the use of harmful collars that cause skin irritation.

It’s a completely safe and natural product that’s designed to treat the cause, not just the symptoms.

13. Calm Me Down

Our rating: 5 / 10

Calm Me Down

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Affordable
  • Made with premium quality fabric and easy to clean
  • The bones come in 3 different colors and the hearts in 2 different colors
  • The sizes are universal
  • The collar has both the prong and spray functions so you can choose the one that suits your needs best
  • Comes with a lifetime guarantee

Cons:

  • The one spray function is not ideal if you want a longer effect as it only takes 30 seconds.

By iDog.

The latest addition to the iDog family is the Calm Me Down Calming Collars for Dog Anxiety. iDog is a trusted brand in the dog training market. The company sells a wide range of products including dog potty training products, dog training remote control toys, dog treadmills, and dog calming collars. The company is both family owned and family run and their mission is to innovate and improve the world of dog care products.

The Calm Me Down Calming Collar features the same safe and effective, long-lasting spray technology as other iDog products. The collar can be used to keep your dog calm in stressful situations.

14. Schmoozies Best Cute Unisex Designer Dog Collar

Our rating: 5 / 10

Schmoozies Best Cute Unisex Designer Dog Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Cute print – great for a small dog
  • Easy to clean – best for frequent washing and cleaning needs
  • Stylish – adds to your dog’s personality
  • Can use as a cooler as well as a collar with the extra water bottle
  • Adjustable to fit any size dog
  • The elastics are soft

Cons:

  • The band is sort of thin but is durable
  • You can’t really use the included water bottle with the cooling pad

With the Schmoozies best Cute unisex dog collar you’ll have the perfect accessorizing that will make your dog more stylish than ever. Thanks to the high-quality materials used in this dog collar, you can be sure you’re getting your money’s worth.

This cute unisex dog collar is versatile and can either be used as a regular collar or as a cooling pad. With the cold water bottle and cooling pack, this works simply by adding cold water to the cooling pad and your ready to go.

15. Adaptil Calming Pheromone Collar

Our rating: 4 / 10

Adaptil Calming Pheromone Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Money back guarantee
  • Works as advertised
  • Invigorating scents for your pup
  • Can cover a large radius

Cons:

  • Plastic material
  • Can get worn out easily
  • Not reusable
  • Has an unpleasant smell

To 30.5 Inch

The Adaptil Calming Pheromone Dog Collar is the best for dogs who are fearful or anxious and can be easily triggered by people or other animals. It’s possible to use this collar to calm your dogs down and help them feel calmer.

The collar works to make a dog feel more at ease and less anxious. This may be coupled with proper discipline because it only works to soothe the dog’s fears temporarily. The Adaptil Calming Collar is not to be used as a substitute for medical treatment but instead as a supplement. Most dogs respond very quickly to the collar (within minutes) however some take longer than others.

16. Comfort Zone Adaptil Collars

Our rating: 4 / 10

Comfort Zone Adaptil Collars

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Highly rated, with an average of 4.7/5 based on 3,683 reviews
  • Available in 4 different sizes
  • Controls anxious behavior in dogs and puppies
  • Effectively masks separation anxiety symptoms
  • Diffuses unpleasant stimuli through pheromones
  • Available in three different types: Adaptil Beads, Adaptil Drops, and Adaptil Collar

Cons:

  • Adaptil Collar may create tangled fur in some cases
  • May take more than a couple weeks to work
  • Effectiveness may vary among dogs
  • Effectiveness may also be affected by external stimuli

Pheromones are chemical signals that are naturally produced by animals. They have an effect on the behavior of other animals of the same species. In pets, Adaptil diffuses Adaptil pheromones through the Adaptil Collar Adaptil Drops, or Adaptil Pheromone Beads. This calms anxious behavior.

17. Sergeant's Vetscription Settle Down Pheromone Collar

Our rating: 4 / 10

Sergeant's Vetscription Settle Down Pheromone Collar

Check Price on Amazon

18. ThunderEase Calming Pheromone Collar

Our rating: 4 / 10

ThunderEase Calming Pheromone Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Proven to be effective for fearful and reactive dogs
  • No negative side effects
  • Available in three sizes
  • Available in three colors

Cons:

  • This is not a substitute for professional behavior training
  • Can require some persistence to see results
  • Collar tends to be scratchy
  • Some dogs seem to grow immune to its calming effects

Adaptil – the manufacturer of ThunderEase – has been helping dogs deal with stress and anxiety since the late ‘90s. Today, it’s one of the market leaders in dog calming products.

True to its name, the ThunderEase Calming Pheromone Collar for dogs works by releasing the same pheromones that a dog uses to communicate with other dogs. If you’ve ever been around a dog that’s anxious or upset and thought they seemed more anxious than they needed to be, you’re probably right. Before domestication, dogs would signal their distress by rolling over and exposing their bellies. This was an invitation to the rest of the pack, who would then come together and help calm the individual down.

19. Calm Paws Calming Collar

Our rating: 4 / 10

Calm Paws Calming Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Made from a high-grade organic cotton and resin blend
  • Comes with a spray diffuser to renew the collar
  • Two sizes – medium and large

Cons:

  • Can irritate sensitive skin
  • Could be too big for some dogs
  • Doesn’t fit on thinner dogs

20. Schmoozies Camouflage Aromatherapy Pet Collar

Our rating: 4 / 10

Schmoozies Camouflage Aromatherapy Pet Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Highly reviewed product
  • Great for older dogs
  • Conforms to the shape of your dog’s neck
  • Affordable price
  • Lasts up to 72 hrs
  • Excellent customer service

Cons:

  • Only scent for calming and doesn’t have a spray setting like others do
  • Hard to remove the vial for refilling
  • Collar doesn’t have a latch to hold it closed
  • Having to unscrew the vial every time you want to refill it can be difficult
  • The collar might not fit dogs with chins

When it comes to calming your anxious dog, it’s important to have a scent that calming. This dog collar does a great job at helping your dog remain calm and relaxed throughout the day. The scent that’s released from the collar not only calms your dog but will also keep mosquitos away.

The Schmoozies camo collar is highly reviewed and customers are very satisfied with their purchase. The only complaint that customers have with the collar is that the vial is hard to open and fill with the scent.

21. ThunderEase Calming Pheromone Collar

Our rating: 3 / 10

ThunderEase Calming Pheromone Collar

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Proven to be effective for fearful and reactive dogs
  • No negative side effects
  • Available in three sizes
  • Available in three colors

Cons:

  • This is not a substitute for professional behavior training
  • Can require some persistence to see results
  • Collar tends to be scratchy
  • Some dogs seem to grow immune to its calming effects

Adaptil – the manufacturer of ThunderEase – has been helping dogs deal with stress and anxiety since the late ‘90s. Today, it’s one of the market leaders in dog calming products.

True to its name, the ThunderEase Calming Pheromone Collar for dogs works by releasing the same pheromones that a dog uses to communicate with other dogs. If you’ve ever been around a dog that’s anxious or upset and thought they seemed more anxious than they needed to be, you’re probably right. Before domestication, dogs would signal their distress by rolling over and exposing their bellies. This was an invitation to the rest of the pack, who would then come together and help calm the individual down.

22. The Good Doggy Calming Bandana

Our rating: 3 / 10

The Good Doggy Calming Bandana

Check Price on Amazon

It’s easy enough to see the value in the sound-reducing magnetic buckle, especially if you’re worried about rousing your dog from sleep when it’s time to put on or take off the collar.

Waterproofing the collar was a great idea. A water-resistant collar is good for outdoor wear, but a waterproof collar is good for indoor use. Dogs can easily get nervous when they’re in their own home, especially if they’re in unfamiliar rooms. A deep-throated bark can disturb the neighbors, but a collar with water-resistant plastic and silicone will keep the water contained. And it holds up well to repeated washings too.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the best calming collar for dogs?

There are many dog calming collars for anxious dogs on the market. I know what you are thinking. There are so many different options out there, how do you know which one to choose?

Your dog is different than your neighbor’s dog. Just like people, dogs have different temperaments and needs. This means that the collar that works best for one might not be the best for another. Factors to consider include the dog’s age, breed, anxiety issues, and how often it is left alone.

A good dog collar is one that works for your dog, is comfortable, and will provide long-lasting results. There is no one size fits all solution. The best collar for you and your dog depends on your specific needs and is dependent on what type of collar is best for your dog.

Do pet calming collars work?

There are a lot of myths surrounding dog calming collars. There is a lot of controversy about the use of a static collar or shock collar. Discussed below are many of the most common myths and a brief scientific explanation of how they work.

What does a calming collar do for dogs?

When a dog is stressed or anxious for some reason, it can make it very difficult for you to correct them if they are barking or lunging at something. When this happens, it can often lead to a bite or an attack which is the opposite of what you want when you’re walking your buddy, or trying to introduce your dog to another dog.

When an owner uses a collar which helps to give their dog a slight shock or pronged sensation when they begin to act poorly, it helps to keep them more calm and prevents them for reacting in a negative manner.

How long does it take for a calming collar to work?

This seems to be a common question. Everyone wants to know how quickly this device is going to work. The answer is: it depends. Some dogs respond quickly, while others take longer. The collars help to reduce anxiety, fear, and phobias in dogs. Dogs with extreme behaviors can take up to four months to respond; however, that is the extreme case. A lot of dogs of all breeds and sizes respond sooner.

Other dogs will require other methods of therapy such as medication, but the collars can be used in conjunction for up to four months. Dogs that respond the quickest are typically small breeds, as well as dogs that are younger.

They often respond because they have less aggression in them and they are eager to please, which means they will respond well to some training.

Conclusion

There are several calming and training collars available on the market, and figuring out which one to buy can seem pretty difficult at first. Luckily in this article, we’ve done that job for you. Our team has tested and researched dozens of different models and after a lot of work, we reviewed the best ones, taking all the negatives and positives into account. We have a conclusion that you will appreciate, so read on if you are interested in getting a good collar at a reasonable price that really works to soothe your dog or cat.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Calm Me DownBest OverallCalm Me Down
NurtureCALM 24/7 Pheromone CollarBudget PickNurtureCALM 24/7 Pheromone Collar
Calm Me DownUpgrade PickCalm Me Down