The Best Dog Crate Pans (2021 Reviews)

Skylar Dial
Written by
Last update:

Whether you’re looking for a a replacement pan for your dog crate or a completely new crate and bedding, this article will help you find the best dog crate pan for your dog and your situation.

Dog crate pans may not seem important to you, but these beds are truly some of the best products you can get for your dog. Crates were designed with dogs in mind, and they don’t scratch and flake like old-fashioned dog beds. They are the perfect way to keep your dog from chewing up your furniture while you’re out, protect your carpet, and help create a consistent and peaceful bedtime routine for your dog.

Because dog crates are far superior to other options, you should make sure that you are choosing a bed that gives your dog the support and comfort he needs. That’s where dog crate pans come in.

There are a number of options to choose from, and we’ll tell you all about them here.

NameCategoryProduct
Replacement PanBest OverallReplacement Pan
You & Me Replacement Dog Crate PanBudget PickYou & Me Replacement Dog Crate Pan
Pet Tek DPK86105 Dream Crate Professional Series 500 Replacement Dog Crate PanUpgrade PickPet Tek DPK86105 Dream Crate Professional Series 500 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

1. Replacement Pan

Our rating: 9 / 10

Replacement Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • True fit for a Great Dane crate
  • Easy to clean
  • Comes only in black color
  • Relieves anxiety in dogs
  • Durable

Cons:

  • Takes two people to assemble the cage and put it together
  • Not enough padding on bottom side of the cage
  • The door – on the size – for the cage – is not as big as it could be, especially if you’re planning on feeding your dog through the cage.

For Great Dane, XL, Black.

2. Midwest Products Co. Dog Plastic Pan 28Pan Size: 21.6" W x 35" D

Our rating: 9 / 10

Midwest Products Co. Dog Plastic Pan 28Pan Size: 21.6" W x 35" D

Check Price on Amazon

Features:
* 48" Length Pans

A good crate is like a backstage pass. It’s kind of a hassle to carry around, but totally worth it when you get to rest in a room of your own.

They’re great for giving your dog a bit of seclusion, while at the same time feeling safe.

3. Everila Replacement Pan

Our rating: 8 / 10

Everila Replacement Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Designed for stronger and heavier, larger dogs
  • It’s made with a solid steel construction
  • Includes a one year warranty
  • Does not rust or break down
  • Lightweight construction
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Has proper drainage to avoid spillage

Cons:

  • May not accommodate new crates completely, so you may need to modify the cage
  • Some may find it hard to assemble because the manufacturing is not as efficient and accurate
  • The pan may need to be lined with a poop bag and secured to the crate to prevent leakages

This heavy duty dog crate pan comes highly recommended and is an excellent choice to replace your old, worn out tray.

Featuring an all-steel construction, it is constructed from long-lasting premium steel materials that would fit a wide range of crates.

They can accommodate various sizes and are compatible for heavy duty use.

4. Replacement Tray

Our rating: 8 / 10

Replacement Tray

Check Price on Amazon

Sizes: Small/Medium/Large/Extra Large/Whole Cage

The Satisfied Pet Replacement Tray is an ideal replacement liner for all pet cages, carriers, carriers, carriers, and kennels.

With deep dimensions and a secure spring-loaded frame design, they offer a great solution to solve any urine or moisture issues and messes.

5. Midwest Solution Series Plastic Pan

Our rating: 8 / 10

Midwest Solution Series Plastic Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Durable plastic pan
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Easy to set up – even if you’ve never put a crate together before
  • Heavy duty door for your dog
  • Great price for the quality and size of the crate

Cons:

  • Louder than the average wire crate because the plastic absorbs more sound
  • The crate is heavy, so it’s only best for indoor use
  • The door is a couple of inches shorter than the one in the original crate

(Black)

Dog crates are fantastic for training and housebreaking as long as they’re used correctly. It helps keep your dog safe and secure, but also makes it easy for you to know when… and when not to… let your dog into certain areas of the house.

The problem that we quickly discovered is that there are so many brands of dog crates on the market, and you’re completely at a loss once it’s time to pick one out. Then on top of that, some brands sell replacement pans, but throw in the word “replacement” in a very nonchalant way. Like, “Oh, just get two of these.

6. Midwest Floor Grid

Our rating: 8 / 10

Midwest Floor Grid

Check Price on Amazon

(TM)(4 Pan Set)

7. Everila 36Lx24W Dog Crate Replacement Tray Galvanized Steel Heavy Duty Metal Pan Floor Size: 35.5Lx23.5Wx1H

Our rating: 8 / 10

Everila 36Lx24W Dog Crate Replacement Tray Galvanized Steel Heavy Duty Metal Pan Floor Size: 35.5Lx23.5Wx1H

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • High-quality construction – doesn’t rust
  • Easy to put in and take out
  • The metal is lightweight
  • Very affordable
  • Give your dog a bath without messing up the crate
  • Originally designed to use for the home and car traveling
  • Great for senior dogs who have arthritis
  • Some customers pointed out using this as a laundry tray

Cons:

  • It doesn’t snap into place
  • Not made for husky dogs
  • Not waterproof
  • Handles are too thin to get a hold when the pan is full
  • Not dishwasher safe

Color Gray.

Dog crates are very essential when it comes to training your dog. It’s the way to house train your dog, as well as prevent your dog from bad behaviors.

However, dog crates can get pretty smelly and yucky after a while. Although dog crates can be washed with soap and water, it’s easier to just throw out the tray and get a replacement.

8. Everila 36Lx23W Dog Crate Replacement Pan Galvanized Steel Heavy Duty Metal Tray Size: 34.5Lx22Wx1H

Our rating: 7 / 10

Everila 36Lx23W Dog Crate Replacement Pan Galvanized Steel Heavy Duty Metal Tray Size: 34.5Lx22Wx1H

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Dog crate tray is designed with pattern locking, avoid the pet from pushing out the tray.
  • The pan is made of galvanized steel, heavy duty and durable for long time use.
  • Comes with 1 year limited warranty.
  • The dimension of the pan is perfect to fit your dog crate, it is also easy to be cleaned.

Cons:

  • Dog crate tray is not waterproof so you have to cover the dog crate while it is wet.
  • The pan is heavier than the previous ones.
  • It is not suitable for small dogs.
  • Dog crate tray cannot fit properly in 36” size dog crate.

With the free standing and top quality kennels, your pet will have a safe and cozy place to rest when traveling. Now you can be stress-free, driving or moving furniture, and your furry friend can enjoy the ride safely. The soft fabric on the padding makes your husband more comfortable. The pad is made of EPS and fiber padding, able to withstand pressure and keep comfortable. We designed the bottom of the pad with mesh bottom, your car will not be dirty when you travel.

9. Petmate Precision Pet 2Door ProValu and Great Crate Replacement Pan

Our rating: 7 / 10

Petmate Precision Pet 2Door ProValu and Great Crate Replacement Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Excellent choice for large dogs
  • Comes with secure latch
  • Sturdy and deep enough to prevent leaks
  • Low maintenance and long lasting
  • Reasonably priced

Cons:

  • Heavy and bulky
  • Can be tricky to set up
  • Not the best for small dogs

Silver.

The Petmate Precision dog crate pan is made for Petsmart and Petco large dog crates. It’s a great choice for a replacement pans because it’s deep and sturdy enough to prevent leaks. The Crateprovalu is sturdy and disposable so you don’t have to worry about cleaning or washing. The instructions are simple enough that you won’t need to consult anyone to assemble the pan.

The pan comes in handy in case your pet urinates directly inside its crate. You can simply replace it with another new one. It’s reasonably priced so you can buy a few of them without breaking the bank.

10. Midwest Side-by-Side Double Door SUV Crate

Our rating: 7 / 10

Midwest Side-by-Side Double Door SUV Crate

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • 3 size options (from 16 x 20 inches to 48 x 36 inches)
  • Double door portable dog crate
  • Top-quality plastic pan
  • 4 inches high
  • Easy to set up and fold flat
  • Perfect for your medium or large dog
  • Deep pan
  • Removable and washable
  • Provide your pooch with maximum comfort and security
  • Heavy-duty hinges

Cons:

  • A bit pricey than other models
  • Some users say that there are some issues on the plastic pan

This dog crate is meant to be used on the backseat of your car. This product is designed with double-door and double-side style to allow access through a front and a side.

11. Everila 48Lx30W Dog Crate Replacement Tray Galvanized Steel Metal Pan Floor

Our rating: 7 / 10

Everila 48Lx30W Dog Crate Replacement Tray Galvanized Steel Metal Pan Floor

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy to install
  • Great for larger dogs
  • Easily cleanable

Cons:

  • Difficult to install as all the tools required are not included with the tray set
  • Came dented upon arrival

If you own a large breed dog – no higher than 6 inches, the Everila pet crate pan could be for you. It is made of high-quality metal construction. And is designed to fit almost all dog crates out there. There is one size for all.

The design of this pan is very unique. It’s designed to avoid your dog from getting their paws wet while drinking water. This also works to keep the flooring from getting damaged due to wear and tear.

This pan is equipped with a drainage system. It’s very useful to prevent over-watering. Without water dripping all over the place.

12. Replacement Pan

Our rating: 6 / 10

Replacement Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • True fit for a Great Dane crate
  • Easy to clean
  • Comes only in black color
  • Relieves anxiety in dogs
  • Durable

Cons:

  • Takes two people to assemble the cage and put it together
  • Not enough padding on bottom side of the cage
  • The door – on the size – for the cage – is not as big as it could be, especially if you’re planning on feeding your dog through the cage.

For Great Dane, XL, Black.

13. Replacement Tray

Our rating: 6 / 10

Replacement Tray

Check Price on Amazon

On the narrow side, the Replacement Tray for Dog Crate by Pinnacle Woodcrafts offers a great solution for the dog owner who’s looking to save money and have their original dog crate replaced.

This crate with a steel frame comes with a full galvanized zinc tray, which serves as an affordable replacement. It’s also coating-free and will require proper cleaning and sealing before use.

The steel frame also has unique L-brackets, which are designed to maximize stability and provide a minimalist, contemporary design.

14. Pinnacle Replacement Pan Medium Dog Crate

Our rating: 6 / 10

Pinnacle Replacement Pan Medium Dog Crate

Check Price on Amazon

Over the years, our pets have become more than family members, they’ve become part of the family, so we want to make sure they have proper accommodations.

Pets need crates to make them feel safe and to keep them confined to a safe place. A while back, we reviewed Pinnacle brand's dog crate pan that was made for metal and wire crates.

Since crate pans are important to have, we figured we’d review another one. This time, we took a look at Pinnacle brand's dog crate pan that is made for the wooden crates.

15. Pet Tek DPK86103 Dream Crate Professional Series 300 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Our rating: 6 / 10

Pet Tek DPK86103 Dream Crate Professional Series 300 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Budget-friendly alternative to Lixit or Rubbermaid dog crate pans
  • Easy to clean
  • Non-toxic, lead free and waterproof
  • Multiple reinforced corner design
  • Large pan size measures 29”L x 19.25”W
  • Fits all sizes of dog crates
  • Easy to install and replace
  • Fits all Largest 36” dog crates (Lixit and Rubbermaid brand dog crates)

Cons:

  • The built-in locks do not work with Briggs and Straten style doors
  • Pan sits loosely in some dog crates
  • Although the pan is non-toxic, non-migrating, and waterproof and made of food grade plastic, some users felt that it is a bit flimsy

Dog Crate Pans are another essential item for your dog crate, especially if you own a wire crate. Dog Crate Pans are also known as Dog Crate Liners.

16. Precision Pet Products Crate Replacement Pan

Our rating: 6 / 10

Precision Pet Products Crate Replacement Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Easy to clean
  • Fits all Precision Automatic Dog Crate
  • Features a comfortable, waterproof bottom
  • Great replacement for the original aging, damaged or soiled crate pan

Not made from recycled materials.

This crate pan from Precision Pet is really easy to clean. Features a comfortable, waterproof bottom, and is great as a replacement for the original aging, damaged or soiled crate pan on your automatic dog crate. The Precision dog crate replacement pan is made with extra thick plastic so the bottom of the crate doesn’t become soaked and wet. Precision’s crate replacement pan is designed to fit all Precision Automatic Dog Crate.

17. Pet Tek DPK86104 Dream Crate Professional Series 400 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Our rating: 6 / 10

Pet Tek DPK86104 Dream Crate Professional Series 400 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Check Price on Amazon

This is the best dog crate pan available on the market for several reasons.

First of all this is probably the cheapest dog crate pan that you can find for a crate this size. Check the weight of your crate when empty if you want to buy a pan that is meant for that specific crate.

Second of all, it is made by Pet Tek, the largest supplier of crate parts. Never buy parts that aren’t made by the original manufacturer for your crate. They will most likely fall apart with time and you’ll end up spending more money on another replacement pan.

18. GoGo Plastic Dog Crate Replacement Pan/Tray

Our rating: 6 / 10

GoGo Plastic Dog Crate Replacement Pan/Tray

Check Price on Amazon

(Clear)

The Pan/Tray for 42-inch plastic dog crate from GoGo is suitable for use as a replacement pad for crates from 42 to 46 inches. It can also be used as a standalone crate if you want to save money the purchase of a separate crate.

The Base and Crate are not included.

19. Pet Tek DPK86101 Dream Crate Professional Series 100 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Our rating: 5 / 10

Pet Tek DPK86101 Dream Crate Professional Series 100 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Check Price on Amazon

If you’re looking for a quality dog crate replacement pan, you’ve come to the right place. Pet Tek’s replacement pans are guaranteed to be leak/tear-proof and will help extend the life of your dog crate. The plastic pan is also designed to prevent rust to keep the dog crate in proper working condition.

Another feature you’d want to look for is a raised lip to avoid spills. Pet Tek’s replacement dog pan boasts a high lip and is splash proof. It also has a diamond plate surface and grooved sides to allow for easy cleaning.

The foam core and the PVC coating protect the dog crate flooring underneath from leaking and cracking. That’s especially important for pets like dogs who are known to “go” at any time of the day.

20. You & Me Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Our rating: 5 / 10

You & Me Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Check Price on Amazon

The You & Me dog crate pans are made from polypropylene material which is lighter and more durable than the aluminum ones.

The cover is made from a mesh material, featuring one side that is waterproof and one side that is breathable. Both of these materials are easy to remove and to wash separately.

While the cover is covered in three rows of velcro to help secure it on the crate.

21. Replacement Crate Pan 36" by MID-WEST 8PAN

Our rating: 4 / 10

Replacement Crate Pan 36" by MID-WEST 8PAN

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • By the Crate Logic website, this crate pan is perfect if you’ve got a slightly bigger dog.
  • One of the reasons that we like it is because it comes with a cheap price tag.

Once you’ve finished the full crate cover, you’ll be able to put it back in place, adding a second layer of protection.

You can also use this crate pan as a replacement if your dog has already taken the original pan. It’s compatible with 8-pans, so you’ll need to find a suitable based for it. You can find that here.

22. Pet Tek DPK86105 Dream Crate Professional Series 500 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Our rating: 4 / 10

Pet Tek DPK86105 Dream Crate Professional Series 500 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Made from commercial-grade, heavy-gauge, galvanized steel, to ensure strength and durability
  • The raised floor design provides your pet with extra space for a more comfortable experience
  • Easy to clean
  • Reduces odors and makes cleaning up after your dog sanitary
  • The clips make it easy to snap on the cover to your crate
  • The cover itself comes with a zipper, to ensure you can adjust it to fit firmly, so your puppy can’t wiggle his way or if out
  • Great travel crate pan, due to its three wire door latches and heavy-duty mesh

Cons:

  • Be wary of the size. The pan comes in XX-Large, so make sure you measure your pet before you order
  • Pelican pro crates fit the pan just fine, however if you’re using Midwest or Variocage, then the measurements may be off ever so slightly

XX-Large, Includes Cover, Great for Puppies and Dogs up to 110 Lbs.

23. DURA-GRIP® Floor Shield and Protector Under Pet Crates

Our rating: 4 / 10

DURA-GRIP® Floor Shield and Protector Under Pet Crates

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Fast and easy to clean
  • Moisture resistant
  • Reduces pet odors
  • Protect floors from urine and other liquid spills
  • Fits standard size pet crates
  • Lightweight and portable
  • Durable and long-lasting
  • Attractive design

Cons:

  • A bit pricey
  • The top and bottom are not treated with grip mat
  • Use with a pet crate liner for more protection.

24. Pet Tek Dreamcrate Pro 600 Crate Replacement Pan 48 x 30 Inch

Our rating: 4 / 10

Pet Tek Dreamcrate Pro 600 Crate Replacement Pan 48 x 30 Inch

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Non-toxic and odor resistant
  • Easy to clean and maintain
  • Extremely durable and sturdy
  • Partition panels for added security and to keep your pets away from each other

Cons:

  • Assembly can be a tad tricky
  • Not very good for dogs who use the bathroom a lot
  • Not suitable for outdoor use

With 4 Doors.

Are you looking for an easy-to-clean dog crate? The Pet Tek Dreamcrate pro 600 pan will be your ‘dream come true.’

This replacement pan comes with a double partioned construction. Which allows you to adjust the size of the dog cage. This also means you can keep your pets separated if you wish.

25. Pet Tek DPK86102 Dream Crate Professional Series 200 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Our rating: 2 / 10

Pet Tek DPK86102 Dream Crate Professional Series 200 Replacement Dog Crate Pan

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Allows you to keep your dog’s food and water bowl in the crate; doesn’t take up space
  • Easy to clean
  • Handles strong chewers well
  • Indestructible; uses patented PVC material
  • Has a unique drainage system
  • Allows waste to be easily removed from surface
  • Can’t be removed by your dog
  • Comes with a free travel bag
  • Backed by a lifetime replacement guarantee

Cons:

  • The wiring in the metal slats could be thinner
  • Can cause tiny dark streaks on the floor

A great dog crate pan has got to be tough enough to withstand some stick chewing, yet still be gentle enough that it doesn’t damage your flooring.

This aluminum dog crate pan does just that. It’s made from waterproof PVC in a design that drains animal waste away from your dog.

Three adjustable legs are fastened directly to the frame, which would help when dealing with strong chewers.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the strongest dog crate?

There are three main qualities to consider when seeking out the strongest dog crate. These are the strength of the individual bars of the crate, the materials that the crate is constructed of, and the weight capacity of the specific crate model.

The strongest dog crate is measured in pounds per square inch (psi). The highest strength-rated crates are generally between 22,000 and 28,000 psi.

The next category is the crate materials. The strongest dog crate is typically constructed of 1/2 carbon steel. Steel is going to be the strongest materials for these crates, assuming it is mixed with another metal for strength. Of course, other strong materials exist, and some crates are made of heavy-duty plastic or tough composite materials, but steel is still the strongest.

Is a bigger dog crate better?

The size of your dog will be the ultimate factor in what size dog crate you should get. Big dogs need big dog crates, smaller dogs need smaller dog crates. Take this into account when you are trying to decide which crate to purchase for your dog.

Are wire or plastic dog crates better?

There isn’t a simple, definitive answer to that question. You can get dog crates of both plastic and wire, and they both have unique benefits and drawbacks. I can’t say for sure which is better, but I can tell you that there are some serious differences.

The shape of the crate plays an important role in the style you choose. For instance, a plastic crate might look more like a home to a dog. A wire crate, on the other hand, gives your dog plenty of airholes for ventilation.

You can also choose between a wired side or one of a plastic. Wire sides make the crate more expensive, but they allow your dog to join you during travel in the car. Plastic allows for ventilation, but it also restricts your dog from being able to travel with you unless you put them in a carrier.

Should dogs have beds in their crates?

After reading this article in the Wall Street Journal a few years ago, I started doing this with our old dog, Nanners. She was such a stress eater that no matter how much we carried her food around with us, she always managed to find snacks that weren't meant for her. Combined with the fact that she was also a compulsive chewer, I knew this would help her mental health and probably keep her from swallowing anything truly dangerous.

We purchased a crate pad that had removable washable covers. That way I could clean them at least once a month without the possibility of killing the dog on a first wash. Every month I carried the covers out to the garage and scrubbed them with a hose. When I was done, I would put her food on the crate pad and leave. She hated the sensation of eating with a wet food pad, but at that point she had learned that the pad came out, and I meant business, and left it alone.

Conclusion

So, with all the information available about dog crate sandbox pans, we thought we’d provide you with a simple list of the best products in the market.

If you are a first time pet owner or just want to keep your puppy away from areas that you do not want them to defecate, we strongly recommend Crate Pad – Tan.

As you browse through the list, you will see that decisions about the best product can differ depending on the preferences that are most important to you, and your pet’s size, activity level, and comfort level.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
Replacement PanBest OverallReplacement Pan
You & Me Replacement Dog Crate PanBudget PickYou & Me Replacement Dog Crate Pan
Pet Tek DPK86105 Dream Crate Professional Series 500 Replacement Dog Crate PanUpgrade PickPet Tek DPK86105 Dream Crate Professional Series 500 Replacement Dog Crate Pan