The Best Plush Dog Toys (2021 Reviews)

Skylar Dial
Written by
Last update:

Our dogs love to play and they are especially interested in any toys that can be stuffed with snacks and treats. Obviously, that puts some serious potential for danger in the mix. The last thing you want to do is give your dog a toy that could become jammed in its mouth or worse, generate an impaction within its stomach.

That’s why we’ve put together this list of the best plush dog toys for aggressive chewers.

These are tested and approved plush dog toys that are actually quite durable.

NameCategoryProduct
ZippyPaws – Woodland Friends BurrowBest OverallZippyPaws - Woodland Friends Burrow
Youngever Durable Plush Dog ToysBudget PickYoungever Durable Plush Dog Toys
P.L.A.Y. PET LIFESTYLE AND YOU P.L.A.Y.Upgrade PickP.L.A.Y. PET LIFESTYLE AND YOU P.L.A.Y.

1. ZippyPaws – Woodland Friends Burrow

Our rating: 9 / 10

ZippyPaws - Woodland Friends Burrow

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Multiple squeakers and crinkles keep dogs engaged for hours
  • The toy itself is very durable
  • The inside stuffing of the burrow can be removed to make it last longer
  • The outer fabric is durable but soft on your dog’s mouth

Cons:

  • All of the compartments have squeakers which automatically makes the dog aim for that one
  • The outside fabric can be damaged when not supervised
  • If your dog has a hard bite, then this toy may not last very long
  • You may need to consider a new toy if your dog has a special squeaker in his toy

This ZippyPaws squeak burrow is sure to make your dog's playtime the most exciting and fun thing ever. It comes with 4 different squeakers so that your dog is always kept stimulated.

The outside of the toy is made of fabric which is durable but soft. The inside of the tunnel is made out of polyester and can be removed for easy cleaning. Simply throw it in the wash when you and your dog need a break from this toy.

This toy promotes safe play as the stuffing can't fall out.

2. Walter The Wabbit Tuff Dog Toy

Our rating: 9 / 10

Walter The Wabbit Tuff Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Has a squeaker
  • Comes in different sizes
  • Affordable price
  • Can also be used as a pillow
  • Made from durable material
  • Great for dogs of all sizes
  • Almost impossible to tear
  • Has stuffing inside to prevent your dog from biting through it
  • Easy to clean
  • Comes in different colors

Cons:

  • The squeaker is quite loud, so expect your dog to make some noise when they hear that
  • Some dogs seem to be attracted to this toy, so it’s best to supervise dogs when they’re playing with this toy.

Our top pick is the Tuff Toy from Walter Pets.This squeaky rabbit toy also doubles as a plush cushion in the house, so what’s not to love about it? As the name suggests, the toy is made from durable material that’s almost impossible to tear. Your dog can play and bite as much as they like, and the toy won’t just fall apart like those toys made from cheap material.

Although word has it that this toy is indestructible, we overly cautious owners take no chances. We’d suggest getting a few of these.

3. Midlee Plush Purse Find-a-Toy Interactive Dog Toy

Our rating: 9 / 10

Midlee Plush Purse Find-a-Toy Interactive Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Lots of treats or kibble can be hidden inside the toy
  • The collar opening has velcro that keeps the opening closed while you hide the treats
  • The opening is not too small and not too large
  • The velcro opening makes it easy for dog to play and easy for owner to fill
  • Doesn’t look like a “toy”
  • Can be used with treats or toys
  • Easy to clean
  • Good size – won’t fit within the mouth of larger dogs

This plush dog toy is a wonderful toy to keep dogs engaged and is perfect for older dogs or for puppies who still enjoy playing with toys. These toys are very chew-able and they are a fun distraction for dogs who really enjoy their toys.

The mouth of the toys is made up of mesh, which makes stuffing the toys a lot easier. These toys take treats and can also hold toys inside, which can make dogs puzzle their minds trying to figure out what they can do to get to their favourite toy.

4. Tick 12" Plush Dog Toy

Our rating: 8 / 10

Tick 12" Plush Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Can hang or lay flat
  • 3 squeakers
  • The squeakers can be removed
  • Made from ultra-soft plush material
  • Size: 10 x 10 x 4 inches
  • For small dogs

Cons:

  • The filling can be a choking hazard
  • Has a very strong smell

The Tick 12" Plush Dog Toy Squirrel is fun and long lasting. It has 3 squeakers inside, and a squeaker can be removed easily. It's made from extremely soft plush material and is light in weight, so it can be carried around easily.

The squeaker is very loud so you're sure your dog will notice it. Some customer review that the squeaker broke after two days of being played with. Others say their dog loved it so much that it gets a bit rough and the squeaker is the first to break.

The stuffing in the Tick 12" Plush Dog Toy Squirrel is all polyester which means it has a lot of give, but can also be a choking hazard if your dog breaks it off. It also has a very strong, non-inebriating, synthetic leather smell which can be off-putting for some.

5. Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Squeaky Puzzle Plush Dog Toy

Our rating: 8 / 10

Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Squeaky Puzzle Plush Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

(2 Pack)

The Outward Hound Hide-A-Squirrel Squeaky Puzzle Plush Dog Toy is a cute and enjoyable toy for dogs of all sizes. Great for any sized dog, it’s a tough little time and comes in three sizes. It’s great for interactive play as your dog will try their hardest to get all the pieces out of the squirrel’s head.

This toy can also be used as a cuddly toy for calmer play sessions. It’s durable, and we definitely like the fact that it’s made from all-natural materials. The squeakers are the only questionable part, but overall a great dog toy.

6. goDog Plush Dog Toy

Our rating: 8 / 10

goDog Plush Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Various sizes so you can pick the size that’s right for your dog
  • These toys come in an assortment of different fun characters
  • These toys are made from high-quality plush materials
  • These toys are great for stuffing in a treat pouch
  • The squeaker in the middle of these toys is guaranteed to bring out the playful side of your dog

Cons:

  • The bandana material on these toys can snag easily
  • Some dogs may rip apart these toys with their teeth
  • These toys aren’t great for rough play

The goDog Plush Dog Toy is one of the most popular items offered by goDog. This company has been making a wide range of toys for dogs for many years, and many of its offering are constantly in high demand.

One of the reasons for this is that goDog is a family business. A family with a dog who has a demand for toys. This means that their toys have been vetted to ensure that they will be enjoyed by the dogs they intend to amuse.

7. Petlou Colossal Rabbit Plush Dog Toy

Our rating: 8 / 10

Petlou Colossal Rabbit Plush Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

The Petlou Colossal Rabbit Winter Plush Dog Toy is a great option for a durable and attractive plush dog toy.

The toy is made with a sturdy cotton exterior and stuffed with the durable and attractive Bionic’s Yarn Blend fiber.

This combination makes for a very durable stuffed toy, for even the roughest dog.

8. Bone Dry DII Crinkle Noise

Our rating: 8 / 10

Bone Dry DII Crinkle Noise

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Heavier weight compared to other toys
  • A “common sense” safety guarantee; the safer option by virtue of having no small pieces and fewer corners
  • Consistency in the manufacturing
  • Can be used for interactive play
  • Can get through stringent testing
  • Well-made
  • Has a squeaker and crinkling sound
  • Large enough (7.5”) for your dog to grab hold of and easily carry
  • Contains all natural cotton and cotton stuffing
  • Encourages a dog’s natural chewing instincts

The Bone DII Crinkle Squeak Dog Toy is a squeaking, crinkle toy that will keep your dog engaged for hours with its realistic textures and sounds.

This toy is made from all-natural materials and the company states that it complies with all regulations for children’s toys.

It is a good toy for safety-conscious dog lovers and owners as it does not contain any small pieces.

9. HuggleHounds Plush Corduroy Durable Knotties Dog Toy

Our rating: 8 / 10

HuggleHounds Plush Corduroy Durable Knotties Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Hugglehounds pride themselves on being fair and honest with their customers, and they do everything to ensure that their customers are satisfied. That’s why they offer a 100% money back guarantee if you decide not to keep the toy, and a one year warranty. This incredible soft plush dog toy is made from extra strong breatheable material, yet it’s still safe enough for your dog to nibble on. It features 6 thick, soft fabric knots which can be chewed on when your pup needs a little chew therapy. When you press the toy on the bottom, the knots oscillate for added enjoyment and engagement. This is great toy for games of catch, however, the knots make it tricky to catch in the air. It’s also great for supervised chewing sessions and this particular model is great for heavy chewers.

10. Multipet Deedle Dude 8-Inch Singing Mouse Plush Dog Toy

Our rating: 8 / 10

Multipet Deedle Dude 8-Inch Singing Mouse Plush Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Multipet Deedle Dude 8-Inch Singing Mouse Plush Dog Toy, Blue.

This fully functional plush talking mouse does a variety of tricks. He rolls, squeaks, scats, sings and GOES. This cute and friendly mouse is a great alternative to the real thing, without all the hassle. Uses 3-AAA batteries (not included).

11. SPOT Skinneeez

Our rating: 8 / 10

SPOT Skinneeez

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Great for indoor/outdoor play
  • Ideal for small and large breeds
  • The squeak is loud and doesn’t easily wear out
  • Stuffing-free
  • Indestructible and well-made
  • Great price, quality ratio
  • Generously sized
  • Machine washable
  • Available in 20 other plush animal designs
  • Comes with its own squeaker

Double Offers Today!

If you’re looking for a great interactive toy for both you and your dog to enjoy, then this is the one for you. The SPOT Skinneeez toy features colorful, soft, and durable plush fabric. It’s ideal for pet to just sit on and play with. Along with a squeaker inside that makes your dog want to play with it even more.

Designed just like your dog’s favorite animals, it has a squeaker inside which makes dogs have a natural desire to play. It’s made to be durable and challenging for dogs, and definitely a great purchase for small and large breeds.

12. Dog Diggin Designs Runway Pup Collection

Our rating: 8 / 10

Dog Diggin Designs Runway Pup Collection

Check Price on Amazon

Dogs are masters at destroying toys, but when it comes to their plush toys, they're determined to keep them in perfect shape from day one.

If your pup is a big fan of the runway scene, then the Dog Diggin Designs runway pup collection is for him. All the popular dogs are featured in this collection in the most fashionable attire you could imagine.

A wide variety of products are available in this collection, from simple squeakers to more complex tunnel play.

13. Youngever Durable Plush Dog Toys

Our rating: 8 / 10

Youngever Durable Plush Dog Toys

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Fun, cute, and funny designs
  • 100% Satisfaction Guarantee

Cons:

  • The squeaker seems to have a high-pitched sound, not like a real squeaker
  • Stitching is a bit problematic, especially around the fastener

Funny Sheep Large Dog Toys, Memory Foam Waterproof Pet Toys.

Youngever Sporting Dog Toys, Ball for Medium and Large Dogs, Durable and High Performance Dog Toys for Chewing, Plush Toys, Set of 4 Dog Tolls.

One thing’s for sure, this is not just your ordinary squeaker toy! With a set of 4 colourful balls, you can expect the dog to have lots of fun. And not to mention, a better sleep after the rigorous playtime.

14. Pawaboo Squeak Plush Dog Toys

Our rating: 8 / 10

Pawaboo Squeak Plush Dog Toys

Check Price on Amazon

Pawaboo is a trusted brand for dog toys, and they make some of the best dog squeaky toys that are made with high-quality materials. This is one of the dog toys by this brand that we’ve chosen for the best dog chew toys reviews. It’s the perfect toy for small to medium sized dogs – it’s 7 inches long and 5.5 inches wide. The squeaker is durable and will last a long while – they’ll stay as new as they were on your first day. This toy is great for teething puppies – it will massage and clean their teeth while keeping them comfortable.

15. Outward Hound Tough Seamz Stuffingless Durable Plush Toy

Our rating: 7 / 10

Outward Hound Tough Seamz Stuffingless Durable Plush Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Comfortable for dogs with sensitive teeth and gums
  • Durable
  • Made with double-liner to prevent the durability for going down
  • Gets softer when licked
  • Isn’t hard like other toys
  • Strong seams
  • Elastic band inside the toys

Cons:

  • Too small for bigger breed dogs
  • The smaller sizes flatten out and dogs don’t even bother with them
  • There’s a smell when you first get the toy that isn’t too pleasant, but goes away when you air the toys out

16. Petbobi Upgrade Dog Toys Interactive Monster Plush Giggle Ball Shake Squeak Crazy Bouncer Toys Exercise Electronic Toy

Our rating: 6 / 10

Petbobi Upgrade Dog Toys Interactive Monster Plush Giggle Ball Shake Squeak Crazy Bouncer Toys Exercise Electronic Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Durable and sturdy toys
  • Come with interactive, voice recording and remote control
  • Easy to setup, fun to play
  • Removable voice box

Cons:

  • Not very strong for larger breeds
  • Voice box is a bit loud
  • Not designed for older dogs

Petbobi knows that dogs love plush toys, and has designed the perfect ball for all you aspiring pet parents.

This plush ball toy for dogs is one of the best toys on our list, simply because of the many things you can teach your dog using it.

Comes with a dog voice recording, this ball has a voice capture function, with which you can record your voice or song on it to help keep your dog amused.

17. P.L.A.Y. PET LIFESTYLE AND YOU P.L.A.Y.

Our rating: 6 / 10

P.L.A.Y. PET LIFESTYLE AND YOU P.L.A.Y.

Check Price on Amazon

9.7

If you’re looking for a simple durable plush toy, then this carrot inspired toy from P.L.A.Y. is a good choice.

This cute plush toy is small but lightweight, and will make a great addition to your dog’s toy collection.

18. ZippyPaws Z-Stitch Snake Dog Toy

Our rating: 6 / 10

ZippyPaws Z-Stitch Snake Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Ideal for games of fetch or water fights
  • Comes in several different sizes
  • Great for the dog that loves strong, durable toys
  • Tuffut Technology’s two-layer fabric is thick and highly resistant to ripping
  • Made with ZippyPaws’ own proprietary fabric, Z-Stitch
  • The squeakers are embedded into the toy, not covered
  • Each toy has 3 squeakers
  • Available in 3 different sizes for small, medium and large dogs
  • Reduces boredom by keeping dogs mentally stimulated
  • High-quality stuffing-free dog toy

19. Petsafe Pogo Plush Toy

Our rating: 6 / 10

Petsafe Pogo Plush Toy

Check Price on Amazon

The Petsafe Pogo Plush Toy For Dogs is one of the most reliable and versatile toys around. Many dog owners place a special order just for this toy.

One of the number one reasons why dog owners order this toy is because of its soft material. It’s made from high-quality plush fabric that’s as soft as velvet on the hands.

20. Outward Hound Kyjen Magic Hat

Our rating: 6 / 10

Outward Hound Kyjen Magic Hat

Check Price on Amazon

This Kyjen Magic Hat with Balls is a plush dog toy that will have your dog occupied for hours on end.

The hat can be opened up to reveal twelve squeaking plush balls.

Dogs who like squeaking toys will enjoy the sound of gently shaking the hat around. So you can expect this will be something that keeps your dog occupied for a long time.

21. KONG Floppy Knots Dog Toy

Our rating: 5 / 10

KONG Floppy Knots Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Soft and durable
  • Flexible material for different uses
  • Helps strengthen the jaws by helping the dog maintain his or her teeth in healthy condition
  • Easy to clean
  • Great for breeds with floppy ears and paws and oversized doggies
  • Can be used as an indoor or outdoor toy
  • Great for interactive games without having to put too much effort
  • Latest design which is made of extra durable material

Cons:

  • Not ideal for small breeds
  • Not exactly cheap

(Small)

When you hear the word KONG, the first thing that comes to mind is durability.

This dog toy is no different. It is made from extra durable material – a combination of rubber and polyester.

22. Martha Stewart Squirrel Plush Dog Toy

Our rating: 5 / 10

Martha Stewart Squirrel Plush Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Decent size
  • Easy to clean
  • Vigourous squeaking and shaking won’t wear out the dog’s interest

It is a soft toy. However, as your dog bites it, the toy will start to decompose.

The Martha Stewart Squirrel is a durable dog toy that is machine washable. It has a firm inner core that is wrapped in soft polyester plush.

It has a squeaker sewn on the inside for added excitement and makes a great companion.

23. Zanies Plush Unstuffies Dog Toy

Our rating: 5 / 10

Zanies Plush Unstuffies Dog Toy

Check Price on Amazon

This unstuff-able plush dog toy from Zanies is soft and close to the real thing, which will greatly appeal to your pup. It features a squeaker that will make playtime more fun for your pup.

Even though they’re soft and squishy, these toy animals are quite durable, and your dog will enjoy playing with them for a while. The different kinds of animals will do the trick to keep your dog happy and entertained.

The downside to these toys is that they’re stuffed with beans instead of air so they’re a bit heavy and bulky for little pups.

24. BeMiracle Dog Chew Toy Squeaky

Our rating: 3 / 10

BeMiracle Dog Chew Toy Squeaky

Check Price on Amazon

For its price, the BeMiracle pet toy is a pretty good value.

It has a generous length (34”) which can be tossed around – even by big dogs – and its innovative material allows it to come back to its original form after being squeezed.

It also has a central hole that dogs can bite through and a squeaker inside, which dogs will love.

25. Fetch Pet Products Hatchables 3 Pack Bundle

Our rating: 3 / 10

Fetch Pet Products Hatchables 3 Pack Bundle

Check Price on Amazon

Pros:

  • Perfect size (small) for most dogs’ mouth
  • Made from durable fabric
  • Easily washable
  • Easy to play with
  • Handmade from start to finish
  • Tough enough to withstand heavy chewing (dog toy)
  • Perfect for small and medium-sized dogs
  • Affordable price

Cons:

  • The squeaker is a bit weak
  • The pet toys are rather small
  • The toy stuffing might be a bit too much for some dogs
  • The toy is a bit pricey

What’s so great about Fetch Pet Products’ Hatchables Pet Toy? It’s a fun and interactive dog toy that gently encourages play time and exercise.

This 3 pack bundle includes a carrot, a hot dog, and a bone design. All three grow in size as your furry friend chews on them. As your dog sharpens his cognitive skills while playing with these deflated toys, you can put a variety of treats in the middle, which they will enjoy ripping out.

It’s a great way to slow down your pooch’s eating habits, and it’s a way to alleviate boredom and other behavioral issues.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

What is the best selling dog toy?

Click on the link for the best selling dog toy.

Are plush toys safe for dogs?

This is a tough question because it really depends on the dog, but in general I say yes. Plush toys are some of my favorite toys to play with my dogs, and they are just about the only type of toys I will let them have when I am not around.

Brands like Kong have been making dog toys for decades, and they are well-respected in the dog-toy industry. Kong dog toys are some of the most durable dog toys you can buy.

What is the most durable dog toy?

My dog loves her hard toys. She can destroy the flimsy ones in less than a day, but the more durable toys last far longer.

There are 3 main types of dog toys • hard plastic, plush, and rope. Here are the pros and cons of each of these.

What is the best dog toy for a heavy chewer?

If your dog is a heavy chewer, my recommendation would be to go with a KONG, either the classic or the ultra. If you are going to choose one, I would recommend the classic.

KONG’s are made from extremely hard rubber, they give your dog something to do that simulates the chewing that they would do in the wild on their bones etc., and the KONG will give them hours and hours of chewing fun.

The quality of the KONGs is also amazing, they last for years, and even when they get chewed down to nothing, they haven't negated their effectiveness. You can also put wet or dry food inside them so you are giving your dog a treat at the same time.

Kangaroo toys (the balls on a rope) are also very good and they bounce, thus entertaining you dog even more.

Conclusion

The most important thing to look for in any plush dog toy is how well it holds up to rough play from your furry friend. If your dog gets bored easily, then stuffing is a major plus. So pay special attention to filling.

We researched dogs, dog toys, and dog owners to help narrow down your choice of best dog toys for your furry friend. We found that the best toys for your dog are the ones that are long-lasting, multi-purpose, and stimulate his or her physical and mental abilities.

Our Recommendation

NameCategoryProduct
ZippyPaws – Woodland Friends BurrowBest OverallZippyPaws - Woodland Friends Burrow
Youngever Durable Plush Dog ToysBudget PickYoungever Durable Plush Dog Toys
P.L.A.Y. PET LIFESTYLE AND YOU P.L.A.Y.Upgrade PickP.L.A.Y. PET LIFESTYLE AND YOU P.L.A.Y.